Deleuzes move here as an opportunity to neatly couple him with lacan, noting triumphantly that the deleuzian quasicause parallels the lacanian objet petit a, the pure, immaterial, spectral entity that serves as the objectcause of desire owb, 27a point deleuze and guattari themselves acknowledge in. But whatever its philosophicotheological obscurities and. Deleuzes selfdeclared antiplatonism fails and that, in badious view, may ultimately be to his credit. When ive read deleuze and guattaris work 24 years ago i wanted desperatly to become a deleuzian. Jacques lacan 3 there, the splits and dissolutions were testimony to a stubborn reluctance to hold the severe position he promoted to the end. Badious text has generated many important controversies and bones of contention. But ive been cautious enough to read all freuds work and lacans among others like foucaults. In the trouble with pleasure, aaron schuster tackles this tangled relationship head on. Perhaps more than any other reader of freud, deleuze has shown that beyond the. The firstthe proper lacanian positionpresents the event as. Each component makes sense only according to its place in the system as a whole. According to badiou, if the first did not escape the ontological identification of.
Jacques lacan, gilles deleuze, edward said, alain badiou and slavoj zizek are in. Deleuze and the lacanian real jacques lacanlacan dot com. For anyone whos carefully followed deleuzes arguments about the logic of representation its clear that this should immediately make ones ears perk up as it suggests an opposition. Through a deep philosophical engagement with his writings, badiou contends that deleuze is not the dionysian thinker of becoming he took himself to be. Badious 1997 book deleuze is an attempt to hold such a discussion. While the combined corpus of these three figures contains a significant number of references to each others work, such references are. Beginning as a commentary on the writings of freud, lacanianism developed into a new psychoanalytic theory of humankind, and spawned a worldwide movement of its own it has been argued that. Or, how to beat your death drive a lecture by aron dunlap duration.
Under the psuedonym georges peyol, badiou penned the fascism of the potato, because if i know anything about resisting fascism, it usually involves declaring enemies of the people and creating a cult of personality around yourself. As for lacan, sartre, althusser, lyotard, deleuze, foucault, and derrida, badiou seemed fairly accurate and always interesting, though its been some time since ive read most of them. It is the first volume of capitalism and schizophrenia, the second being a. In this bold and provocative work, french philosopher alain badiou proposes a startling reinterpretation of st. Counterinsurgency manual, because we are dealing with an insurgency. For badiou, paul is neither the venerable saint embalmed. His contentions with deleuze over multiplicity, ontology, truth and the event among other things have already sparked numerous responses in various forms. Lacan deleuze badiou guides us through these crucial, underremarked interrelations, identifying the conceptual passages, connections and disjunctions that underlie the often superficial statements of critique, indifference or agreement. Badiou has written about the concepts of being, truth and the subject in a way that, he claims, is neither postmodern nor simply a repetition of. Countering ideas of the philosopher as a dogmatic, absolutist, or even mystical thinker enthralled by the force of the event as a radical break, bruno bosteels reveals badious deep and ongoing investment in the dialectic. Lacanian ontology, that question posed bluntly enough by jacquesalain miller. Adam bartlett, justin clemens and jon roffe, lacan deleuze badiou eup. A life is composed of a single and same event, lacking all the variety of what happens to. The work of resistance lyat friedman 83 literature as symptomatology.
Between the two models, there is a lacanian subjectivation that badiou. Alain badiou, jacques lacan and the ethics of teaching. There is only one other, with whom discussion might nave been possible, were it not for the fact of his death. However, if one expects this to be an indepth commentary or critique on deleuzian thought, prepare to be disappointed. The clamor of being presents deleuze as an aristocratic philosopher of the one, a nietzschean vitalist who isnt too far removed from platos parmenidies in continually affirming that there is only one path to being. This contrasts with the lacan pole which puts lack at the centre of desire. This book can be seen as a guide to reading deleuze, but at the same time it is a direct confrontation with issues at stake, particularly the debate with and against psychoanalysis.
Scruton is brilliant at the patient demolition, in sorrowful yet. Reviewed by adrian johnston, university of new mexico the infamous french psychoanalyst jacques lacan undeniably casts a long shadow over the past several decades of continental philosophy. Lacan, deleuze and world politics rethinking the ontology of the political subject. Badiou himself has proposed thinking of twentiethcentury french philosophy in terms of an ongoing debate between vitalism and formalism. It had become good form to state that the ageing lacan was no longer transmitting anything worthwhile from the 1970s onwards. These readers will find abstracts of selected concepts, directed. Organs without bodies was an interesting and even entertaining read. The focus of this paper is the lacanian legacy in alain badiou. Across the span of western thought, infinity has been a notoriously troublesome idea, difficult to pin down, full of paradox, and seemingly connected in some way or other with the divine. Badious view but disagrees with the suggestion that deleuzeguattari can. Lacans work must be read as presupposing the entire content of. The first are those new to the work of alain badiou, gilles deleuze and jacques lacan. Jacques derrida, and gilles deleuze, suggesting how and why badious work differs from. Deleuze or lacan peter hallward 33 desire and the dialectics of love.
Indeed, there is no greater difference between badiou and deleuze than in their. An apprenticeship in resistance may 68 and the power of. It is often said that lacan is the most radical representative of structuralism, a thinker of negativity and alienation, whereas deleuze is pictured as a great opponent of the structuralist project, a vitalist and a thinker of creative potentialities of desire. Lacanianism is the study of, and development of, the ideas and theories of the dissident french psychoanalyst jacques lacan. Badiou translated directly from the french editions deleuze, ethics, saint. Id be lying if i said i wasnt a little bit glad to be done with this book, and panthson only because some of it was obscure and impenetrable to me. It is a philosophy of the extraordinary under the platonic sign of the same, a philoso. In deleuze, diffence refers to the multiple singularities which express the one of infinite life, while, with badiou, we get multitudes without any underlying one ness. Slavoj zizek and alain badiou discuss in what ways jacques lacan can be understood as a philosopher as antiphilosopher, and eventually antiantiphilosopher, and how his work relates to. Metapolitics, alain badiou, 2005, philosophy, 159 pages. A reconfiguration of the reception of deleuze and lacan in contemporary continental philosophy.
Yet, in spite of obvious differences, of style and stance, the. Influenced by plato, georg wilhelm friedrich hegel, jacques lacan and gilles deleuze, he is an outspoken critic of both the analytic as well as the postmodern schools of thoughts. Leibnitz et le baroque is a book by gilles deleuze which offers a new interpretation of the baroque and of. Badious steadfast opposition to the philosophical supremacy of meaningthat is, his attempt to resurrect rationalism against the many faces of. In previous columns, i have explored the ontology, theory of the state, theory of the event, and political views of alain badiou. While the combined corpus of these three figures contains a significant number of references to each others work, such references are often simply critical, obscure or both.
Pdf this essay explores badious writings on art and inaesthetics. The result is neither a lacanian reading of deleuze nor a deleuzian reading of lacan but rather a systematic and comparative analysis that identifies concerns common to both thinkers and their ultimately incompatible ways of addressing them. The book rather seems to be a collection of essays that sometimes encounter the thought of deleuze, but other thinkers as well such as alain badiou. Badiou s 1997 book deleuze is an attempt to hold such a discussion. Deleuze, canguilhem, and the philosophy of desire christian kerslake 51 antioedipus. Among many other things, logics of worlds is also the invention of a new articulation between. Zizek reads in deleuzes corpus two different ontologies, one engaged with in his solo work and the other in his collaborations with guattari.
Lacans act and badious event if the void of the real is the most basic element shared by lacan and badiou, it is crucial to examine the excess that correlates with it. The theoretical writings of jacques lacan, gilles deleuze and alain badiou stand at the heart of contemporary european thought. This debate not only offers the occasion to find an entrance to deleuzes basic thought, but. For deleuze this is like saying negation is the centre of becoming since the whole project of plateaus is to create a concept of desire as the productive force of life. Gilles deleuze on sachermasoch tomas geyskens 103 deleuze with masoch ericalliez 117. Alain badiou, jacques lacan and the ethics of teaching article in educational philosophy and theory 422. The great and peculiar interest of badious work is that it links lin the most rigorous terms a philosophy of the extraordinary of the event with a philosophy of the absolutely generic as such. What is serious for lacan is the logic of the signifier, that is to say the opposite of a philosophy, inasmuch as every philosophy rests on the appropriateness, transparency, agreement, harmony of thought with itself. Firstly, the article shows how badiou uses lacanian categories in order to. Deleuze with being and event recently translated, alain badiou has now enjoyed over a decade of philosophical clamor in english. Badiou declared deleuze an enemy of the people and penned several antideleuze articles. Wandering fidelity the state of the political in badiou. Badiou and politics offers a muchanticipated interpretation of the work of the influential french philosopher alain badiou.
1607 621 36 1011 1479 1337 705 876 508 895 39 1443 681 1548 729 1196 358 750 107 1117 329 1381 1378 1234 480 182 755 580 225 1333 1180 647